Madeline Brewer is best known for her portrayal of Janine in Hulu’s Emmy Award and Golden Globe-winning series The Handmaid’s Tale, a role that earned her an Emmy nomination for Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series. The sixth and final season of the series, based on Margaret Atwood’s best-selling novel, was released in April 2025 to wide critical acclaim.
Madeline is currently in production on Paramount Pictures’ Possession, alongside Margaret Qualley and Callum Turner. Last year she appeared in the fifth and final season of Netflix’s YOU opposite Penn Badgley, portraying Bronte, an enigmatic and free-spirited playwright who joins Joe Goldberg’s bookstore staff and sparks in him a nostalgia for his former self, prompting him to question the life he has built. The season quickly rose to the number one spot on Netflix’s global charts. She previously starred in Lionsgate’s thriller Anniversary alongside Kyle Chandler, Phoebe Dynevor, Diane Lane, and Zoey Deutch.
Madeline’s theater work includes her Broadway turn in the title role of the Tony Award-nominated revival of Becky Shaw, marking her Broadway debut. She previously earned acclaim for her performance as Sally Bowles in the Olivier Award-winning London production of Cabaret at the Playhouse Theatre, opposite Callum Scott Howells. She also recently completed an Off-Broadway run as Audrey in Little Shop of Horrors at the Westside Theatre and appeared in the Off-Broadway production of The Disappear, a new comedy from Audible Theater, alongside Kelvin Harrison Jr., Dylan Baker, and Hamish Linklater. Madeline will next be seen in the titular role of Rose in New York Theatre Workshop’s Off-Broadway production of Wild Rose.
Additional credits include Focus Features’ Captive State, directed by Rupert Wyatt and featuring Ashton Sanders and Vera Farmiga; Hustlers, opposite Constance Wu and Jennifer Lopez; The Ultimate Playlist of Noise for Hulu and American High, alongside Keean Johnson; Space Oddity, directed by Kyra Sedgwick with Kevin Bacon and Alexandra Shipp, which premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival; I Live Here Now with Lucy Fry; the thriller Where Are You with Anthony Hopkins and Angela Sarafyan; as well as Flesh and Blood, directed by Mark Webber, which premiered at SXSW; Hedgehog with Ann Dowd, which screened at Cinequest; and Open Road’s Separation with Brian Cox and Rupert Friend.
Madeline made her television debut as fan-favorite Tricia Miller in Netflix’s original comedy-drama series Orange is the New Black, created by Jenji Kohan. She also starred in Netflix’s critically acclaimed series Black Mirror, in the episode “Men Against Fire,” with Malachi Kirby and Michael Kelly. Other television roles include Miranda Cates in Eli Roth’s Hemlock Grove for Netflix, Julie Kelly in Bret Easton Ellis’ series The Deleted for Fullscreen, and guest roles on Grimm and Stalker.
Born in Philadelphia and raised in Pitman, NJ, Madeline is a graduate of AMDA, the American Musical and Dramatic Academy, in New York City, where she studied musical theater. Immediately after graduating, she landed the lead role in the world premiere of Liberty: The Musical. Madeline is also a classically trained singer.
Our theatre uses reserved seating and accessibility accommodations include wheelchair-accessible seating, wide seats, assistive listening devices and large print programs. Learn more about accessing our buildings and contact us with questions at LetsChat@nytw.org.
Theatre isn’t a luxury, it’s a necessity—a vital part of our culture that should be available to all. So, we’re doing our part to remove obstacles that keep people from coming through our doors. At the end of the day, we want to make one thing clear: YOU BELONG HERE!
From director JOHN TIFFANY:
“Returning to New York Theatre Workshop with a new musical is incredibly meaningful to me and a homecoming in many ways. This is a place that champions bold work and intimate storytelling. It is the perfect fit for Wild Rose as we introduce this deeply human story about spirit and resilience and hope to New York audiences for the first time.”
From writer and creator NICOLE TAYLOR:
“There is no character I’ve ever written or will write who means more to me than Rose-Lynn Harlan. From the moment she roared into my mind, fully formed, I imagined her both on the stage and on the screen. Growing up as a country music obsessed kid in Scotland, how I longed to escape what felt like a very emotionally inexpressive culture and go to the source of this music that meant everything to me. In a very thrilling case of life imitating art, here we are bringing the show to America, and I am so delighted to be working with the great John Tiffany. I cannot wait to share this story of mothers and daughters, reality and dreams with American audiences.”
From NYTW Artistic Director PATRICIA McGREGOR:
“Fall 2026 is marked by homecomings. It’s been 15 years since the wonderful John Tiffany and Steven Hoggett collaborated at NYTW to bring us the unforgettable Once. We are thrilled to welcome them back to East 4th Street with Nicole Taylor’s gorgeous film-turned-musical examination of motherhood and how far we’ll go in pursuit of our dreams.”
★★★★ “A TREMENDOUS NIGHT OUT.” –Across the Arts
★★★★★ “An ABSOLUTE TRIUMPH.” –All Edinburgh Theatre
★★★★★ “Hit me full-force and LEFT ME VIRTUALLY BREATHLESS.” –ScotsGayArts
★★★★ “A FAST-MOVING, HEART-GRABBING new musical.” –The Observer
“Director John Tiffany has pulled off another feat of THEATRICAL ALCHEMY.” –The Sunday National
The world premiere of Wild Rose debuted at The Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh in 2025. The musical is based on the film of the same title, written by Nicole Taylor, directed by Tom Harper and produced by Faye Ward for Fable Pictures and released in 2018.
Sign up here to receive announcements about Wild Rose!
Bios are provided by each artist. Where opinions are expressed, they represent individual views. We ask everyone attending an event to read and embrace the NYTW Core Values. If you’d like to tell us about your experience at NYTW, email us at LetsChat@nytw.org.